Game Rankings per Console

The title pretty much speaks for itself - I've listed every game I've played for each console - of course, keeping with our 15-year nostalgia rule, only ones released 2010 and earlier - and ranked them per console on a 0-100% scale. :)

Nintendo Wii

  1. Metroid Prime Trilogy (96%)
  2. Super Mario Galaxy 2 (95%) [Ongoing LP]
  3. Super Mario Galaxy (93%)
  4. Super Smash Bros. Brawl (93%)
  5. The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess (91%)
  6. Mario Kart Wii (85%)
  7. Super Mario All-Stars (85%)
  8. Donkey Kong Country Returns (85%)
  9. New Super Mario Bros. Wii (83%)
  10. Super Paper Mario (79%)
  11. Sonic Colors (78%)
  12. Endless Ocean (77%)
  13. Tetris Party Deluxe (77%)
  14. WarioWare: Smooth Moves (77%)
  15. Mario Strikers Charged (75%)
  16. Mario & Sonic at the Olympic Winter Games (75%)
  17. Excite Truck (74%)
  18. Deadly Creatures (74%)
  19. Wii Sports (72%)
  20. Disney Epic Mickey (72%)
  21. Mario Party 8 (70%)
  22. Metroid: Other M (69%) [LP]
  23. Mario & Sonic at the Olympic Games (68%)
  24. Sonic the Hedgehog 4: Episode I (68%) [LP]
  25. Trivial Pursuit (68%)
  26. Pokémon Battle Revolution (67%)
  27. Sonic and the Black Knight (66%)
  28. The Sims 3 (62%)
  29. Red Steel (60%)
  30. Sonic and the Secret Rings (59%)

Xbox 360

  1. The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion (91%)
  2. Resident Evil 5 (82%)
  3. FIFA Soccer 09 (79%)
  4. FIFA Soccer 10 (78%)
  5. FIFA Soccer 11 (77%)
  6. Dead or Alive 4 (75%)
  7. The Darkness (75%)
  8. FIFA Soccer 08 (73%)
  9. Sonic Unleashed (73%)
  10. Dragon Ball Z: Burst Limit (72%)
  11. UEFA EURO 2008 (72%)
  12. MotoGP '07 (71%)
  13. Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts (71%)
  14. 2010 FIFA World Cup South Africa (71%)
  15. Winning Eleven: Pro Evolution Soccer 2007 (70%)
  16. Kameo: Elements of Power (69%)
  17. Amped 3 (68%)
  18. FIFA World Cup: Germany 2006 (67%)
  19. FIFA 07 Soccer (65%)
  20. Perfect Dark Zero (61%)
  21. Sonic the Hedgehog (46%)

Nintendo DS

  1. Pokémon SoulSilver Version (94%)
  2. Pokémon HeartGold Version (92%)
  3. Pokémon Platinum Version (89%)
  4. Tetris DS (85%)
  5. Mario Kart DS (85%)
  6. Pokémon Diamond Version (84%)
  7. Bomberman 2 (83%)
  8. Advance Wars: Dual Strike (83%)
  9. Pokémon Pearl Version (82%)
  10. Super Mario 64 DS (81%)
  11. New Super Mario Bros. (81%)
  12. Sonic Rush Adventure (78%)
  13. WarioWare: Touched! (78%)
  14. Sonic Classic Collection (76%)
  15. Sonic Rush (74%)
  16. Monopoly (74%)
  17. Trace Memory (73%)
  18. Yoshi's Island DS (73%)
  19. Bomberman (72%)
  20. Nintendogs: Lab & Friends (70%)
  21. Petz: Hamsterz 2 (65%)
  22. Polarium (64%)
  23. Metroid Prime: Hunters - First Hunt (62%)

Nintendo GameCube

  1. Resident Evil 4 (98%)
  2. The Legend of Zelda Collector's Edtiion (97%)
  3. Super Smash Bros. Melee (96%)
  4. Resident Evil (94%)
  5. Metroid Prime (94%)
  6. The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker (93%)
  7. Pikmin 2 (88%)
  8. Resident Evil 2 (87%)
  9. F-Zero GX (86%)
  10. Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem (86%)
  11. Metroid Prime 2: Echoes (86%)
  12. TimeSplitters 2 (85%)
  13. Mario Kart: Double Dash!! (85%)
  14. Resident Evil 3: Nemesis (85%)
  15. Sonic Adventure 2 Battle (84%)
  16. SoulCalibur II (84%)
  17. Animal Crossing (84%)
  18. Sonic Mega Collection (83%)
  19. Pikmin (82%) [LP]
  20. Super Mario Sunshine (82%)
  21. Luigi's Mansion (81%)
  22. Resident Evil 0 (78%) [Ongoing LP]
  23. Sonic Gems Collection (77%)
  24. WarioWare, Inc.: Mega Party Game$! (76%)
  25. Super Mario Strikers (76%)
  26. Sonic Adventure DX: Director's Cut (76%)
  27. Call of Duty: Finest Hour (75%)
  28. Dragon Ball Z: Budokai 2 (75%)
  29. Mario Party 6 (75%)
  30. Mario Party 7 (73%)
  31. Mario Party 5 (73%)
  32. Wave Race: Blue Storm (73%)
  33. Star Fox Adventures (72%)
  34. Mario Party 4 (72%)
  35. Wario World (71%)
  36. Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six 3 (70%)
  37. Donkey Konga (69%)

Xbox

  1. Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas (90%)
  2. Halo: Combat Evolved (87%)
  3. Burnout 3: Takedown (85%)
  4. Halo 2 (84%)
  5. Oddworld: Stranger's Wrath (84%)
  6. Psychonauts (84%)
  7. Dead or Alive Ultimate (84%)
  8. Fable (79%)
  9. Conker: Live & Reloaded (79%)
  10. Burnout Revenge (78%)
  11. The Sims Bustin' Out (74%)
  12. Midtown Madness 3 (74%)
  13. Second Sight (73%)
  14. Oddworld: Munch's Oddysee (72%)
  15. Digimon Rumble Arena 2 (72%)
  16. Terminator 3: The Redemption (70%)
  17. Sonic Heroes (69%)
  18. Shadow the Hedgehog (66%)

PlayStation 2

  1. Dragon Ball Z: Budokai 3 (84%)
  2. Dragon Ball Z: Budokai Tenkaichi 2 (83%)
  3. World Soccer Winning Eleven 9 (81%)
  4. Sega Genesis Collection (76%)
  5. Dragon Ball Z: Budokai Tenkaichi (73%)
  6. Sonic Riders (70%)

Game Boy Advance

  1. Super Mario World: Super Mario Advance 2 (89%)
  2. Pokémon Emerald Version (89%)
  3. Metroid: Zero Mission (88%)
  4. Super Mario Advance 4: Super Mario Bros. 3 (87%)
  5. Yoshi's Island: Super Mario Advance 3 (87%)
  6. Metroid Fusion (87%)
  7. Pokémon LeafGreen Version (86%)
  8. Pokémon FireRed Version (86%)
  9. Donkey Kong Country 2 (84%)
  10. Pokémon Sapphire Version (84%)
  11. Pokémon Ruby Version (83%)
  12. Donkey Kong Country (83%)
  13. Wario Land 4 (79%)
  14. Donkey Kong Country 3 (77%)
  15. Super Mario Advance (76%)
  16. Sonic Advance 3 (75%)
  17. Mario Kart: Super Circuit (75%)
  18. Sonic Advance (74%)
  19. Sonic Advance (74%)
  20. Kuru Kuru Kururin (73%)
  21. Banjo-Kazooie: Grunty's Revenge (68%)
  22. No Rules: Get Phat (36%)

Nintendo 64

  1. Super Mario 64 (94%) [LP]
  2. Banjo-Kazooie (91%) [LP]
  3. Banjo-Tooie (90%)
  4. Super Smash Bros. (87%)
  5. Mario Kart 64 (86%)
  6. F-Zero GX (82%)
  7. Donkey Kong 64 (79%)
  8. Mario Party 2 (79%)
  9. Diddy Kong Racing (79%)
  10. Mario Party 3 (78%)
  11. Pokémon Puzzle League (77%)
  12. Mario Party (76%)
  13. Pokémon Stadium (74%)
  14. Pokémon Snap (73%)
  15. Bomberman 64 (73%)
  16. Blast Corps (73%)
  17. Turok: Dinosaur Hunter (72%)
  18. Yoshi's Story (70%)
  19. Quest 64 (60%)
  20. V-Rally Edition '99 (60%)

PlayStation

  1. Gran Turismo (79%)
  2. Oddworld: Abe's Exoddus (79%)
  3. Oddworld: Abe's Oddysee (78%) [Ongoing LP]
  4. Formula 1 (72%)
  5. Need for Speed: V-Rally (64%)
  6. This Is Football (64%)
  7. World Cup Golf: Professional Edition (55%)

Super Nintendo

  1. The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past (98%) [LP]
  2. Super Mario World (98%)
  3. Super Metroid (95%)
  4. Super Mario All-Stars (93%)
  5. Donkey Kong Country 2 (92%) [LP]
  6. Donkey Kong Country (89%) [LP]
  7. Super Street Fighter II (87%)
  8. Donkey Kong Country 3 (84%) [Ongoing LP]
  9. Super Mario Kart (82%)
  10. Harvest Moon (80%)
  11. Super Bomberman 2 (76%)
  12. Pilotwings (72%)
  13. WWF Super WrestleMania (57%)

Game Boy Color

  1. Pokémon Crystal Version (92%)
  2. Pokémon Silver Version (92%)
  3. Pokémon Gold Version (91%)
  4. Super Mario Bros. Deluxe (82%)
  5. Wario Land 3 (79%)
  6. Donkey Kong Country (77%)
  7. Pokémon Pinball (71%)
  8. LEGO Racers (64%)

Game Boy

  1. Pokémon Blue Version (87%)
  2. Pokémon Red Version (87%)
  3. Pokémon Yellow Version (86%)
  4. Tetris (85%)
  5. Donkey Kong (84%)
  6. Super Mario Land 2: 6 Golden Coins (81%)
  7. Super Mario Land 3: Wario Land (79%)
  8. Wario Land II (79%)
  9. Donkey Kong Land 2 (74%)
  10. Super Mario Land (73%)
  11. Mickey Mouse: Magic Wands! (72%)
  12. Donkey Kong Land (70%)
  13. BurgerTime Deluxe (68%)
  14. Tennis (63%)
  15. Yoshi (63%)
  16. Mickey's Dangerous Chase (62%)
  17. The Smurfs (62%)
  18. Golf (60%)
  19. Daffy Duck (59%)
  20. Terminator 2: Judgment Day (51%)
  21. Spider-Man / X-Men: Arcade's Revenge (51%)

Sega Genesis

  1. Sonic & Knuckles (90%)
  2. Sonic the Hedgehog 2 (90%)
  3. Sonic the Hedgehog 3 (89%)
  4. Sonic the Hedgehog (81%) [LP]
  5. Disney's Aladdin (76%)
  6. Road Rash II (75%)
  7. NHL Hockey (72%)
  8. The Lion King (70%)
  9. Michael Jackson's Moonwalker (70%)
  10. FIFA International Soccer (69%)
  11. Donald in Maui Mallard (69%)
  12. World Series Baseball (68%)
  13. Triple Score: 3 Games in 1 (66%)
  14. Pitfall: The Mayan Adventure (65%)
  15. Star Trek: Deep Space Nine - Crossroads of Time (64%)
  16. The Smurfs (62%)
  17. Ultimate Soccer (61%)
  18. Mario Lemieux Hockey (60%)
  19. World Trophy Soccer (60%)
  20. Spider-Man (58%)
  21. World Championship Soccer (56%)
  22. Shadow of the Beast (54%)
  23. David Robinson's Supreme Court (53%)
  24. Jordan vs. Bird (52%)
  25. Super Kick Off (37%)

NES

  1. Super Mario Bros. 3 (98%)
  2. Super Mario Bros. (85%)
  3. Disney's Chip 'n Dale: Rescue Rangers (77%)
  4. Super Mario Bros. 2 (76%) [LP]
  5. NES Open Tournament Golf (60%)
  6. Digger T. Rock: The Legend of the Lost City (60%)